Find Dealers

Primacy All Season TIRE REVIEW

There are 187 reviews for the Primacy All Season

Bibendum icon

Rating Snapshot

3/5
45 %
For any matter regarding customer service (in-store experience, after-sales service, delivery, etc.) please contact our Consumer Care team

Review Summary

The Michelin Primacy tires received mixed reviews. Some customers reported the tires as quiet, comfortable, and providing good road grip and handling. However, many customers experienced rapid and uneven tread wear, poor performance in wet or snowy conditions, and even tire blowouts. Customers were generally disappointed with the durability and lifespan of the tires, often needing to replace them well before the expected treadlife.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

141-150 on 187 reviews

Sort by

Review Details

  • Photo
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • 2different tires
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • Grooved roads, which are now my biggest nightmare
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • Brought my car to the dealership to get inspected and they told me I have a gash in my tire. And someone told me it looks like the tire is coming apart
  • Photo
  • Photo
1 20
Posted On April 18, 2026 by Jim L
1/5

Flat tire after 900 miles

Just purchased Cadillac LYRIQ.900 miles. Flat tire in my garage. Small piece of mulch wood barely in the tire. No spare. Reading these reviews are scaring me that these tires are going to be an issue especcially with no run flat or spare tire. Supposedly self-sealing per dealer. They certainly didn't self seal as tire went completely flat in my garage.Worried in Florida.

Posted on michelinman.com
Posted On January 14, 2024 by Anonymous
Collected by Bazaarvoice
1/5

Noisy and terrible in the snow.

These came on my 2023 Rav 4 Limited. They are noisy and absolutely worthless in the snow. I’m a native Colorado driver. I know how to drive in the snow. I never felt more unsure in driving than on these tires.

Posted on michelinman.com

JC 1961, we're sorry to hear of your disappointment in the Primacy All Season. We'd suggest that you have the tires inspected by an authorized Michelin retailer, and have the dealer call us with their findings while you are there.

michelinman.com

February 15, 2024

Posted On January 12, 2024 by Anonymous
Collected by Bazaarvoice
3/5

Average

For everyone complaining about these tires on EVs give your head a shake. A Ford lightning weighs nearly as much as a 1 ton diesel and these are passenger rated tires. Even a Nissan leaf is significantly heavier than an ICE vehicle of the same class. They are average tires.

Performance
3
Safety
4
Appearance
4
Purchase date: 22-12-12
Posted On December 19, 2023 by Anonymous
Collected by Bazaarvoice
1/5

AVOID PRIMACY MXM4 A/S -- horrible tires

I bought Primacy mxm4 earlier in DEc. HORRIBLE, HORRIBLE, HORRIBLE -- AVOID THEM! They are LOUD, hard, very low rolling resistance which leads to a feeling of no/low performance, no grip, etc. I wapped them for Pilot Sport 4 all season, which is a ZR rated tire. Feel and preformance on those are better, but the Pilot Sport is LOUD, too - just not as loud as these utterly miserable Primacy mxm4. I am surprised that Michelin even offers these horrible tires. Not in any way like the wonderful Michelin tires of yesteryear, upon which the Company built its previously well-earned reputation

Posted on michelinman.com

Disappointed, sorry to read that you were unhappy with the Primacy All Season tires. Glad you were able to take advantage of the Michelin Promise Plan 60 day satisfaction guarantee.

michelinman.com

December 29, 2023

Posted On December 10, 2023 by Anonymous
Collected by Bazaarvoice
1/5

20,000 miles MAX

These tiers were on my 2022 ford lighting when I bought it NEW Jan. 2023. By August they were more than half warn. Dec1st. 2023 30000 miles, belts are showing? Not a good value.

Posted on michelinman.com
  • Photo
  • Photo
1 2

Tim, we are sorry to read that you are disappointed in the treadwear of the original tires on your Ford Lightning. Give us a call at 866-866-6605 to discuss optional tires for your application.

michelinman.com

February 29, 2024

Posted On December 5, 2023 by Anonymous
Collected by Bazaarvoice
1/5

Make your dealer take these off your vehicle before you sign the paperwork.

If i could give zero stars i would. Tred life horrible. Traction is questionable once the tred wears a bit.

Posted on michelinman.com

Bad, we're sorry to read of your disappointment in the original tires on your vehicle. Please give us a call at 866-866-6605 to discuss optional tires for your application.

michelinman.com

February 29, 2024

Posted On November 11, 2023 by Anonymous
Collected by Bazaarvoice
1/5

2 blowouts in less than a month

2 blowouts drivers front in less than 4 weeks.

Posted on michelinman.com
Photo

Deecee, we're sorry to read this. The first step is to have the tire(s) inspected by an authorized Michelin retailer, as they can assist with warranty issues. Have the dealer call us with an inspection of the tires while you are there.

michelinman.com

December 18, 2023

Posted On October 19, 2023 by Anonymous
Collected by Bazaarvoice
3/5

limited tread life

So far I have 26000 miles on these tires as OEM on my Nissan Leaf. The Nissan dealer informed me today that the tread is wearing down to almost a point of replacement. I can't see how these tires can be rated for 55K miles.

Posted on michelinman.com

Nly, the original tires on your Nissan Leaf have a warranty to cover workmanship and materials, however there is no mileage warranty on original equipment tires.

michelinman.com

December 13, 2023

Posted On September 7, 2023 by Anonymous
Collected by Bazaarvoice
1/5

Don't get these tire, I bought my Rav4 Hybrid XLE last year in the end of June, and this tire is the OEM tire. And front right tire is Flat within 15k mile.

Posted on michelinman.com
Photo

Bill, we're sorry to read that you experienced an issue with a tire. The first step is to have the tire inspected by an authorized retailer. One of our team members will be in touch to work with you and the retailer on a warranty claim.

September 11, 2023

Posted On August 29, 2023 by Anonymous
Collected by Bazaarvoice
2/5

EVEN GREAT BRANDS HAVE A CRAPPY MODEL. MEET MICH'S...

These were the OEM tires to my 2020 Ford Explorer Limited. Michelin is a brand that one time had my ultimate confidence and trust. If my vehicle had Michelin tires, I was not concerned. This is no longer the case. At 40,000 miles, I grew very concerned about the tread life left on the tires. While the tire LOOKED shiny-new from a distance, upon close review, I have seen some SCARY things. One tire even seems to have tiny pinholes in the sidewall, like someone took a stamp and pressed into the side of the tire. They just don't appear to hold up over time and it made for an extremely tense trip on the road this past weekend. In 110-degree temps, with tire remnants on the sides of the road as a perpetual reminder to you of blowouts that have recently occurred, this was the most unnerved my tires have ever made me while on a trip and I have BEEN through multiple blowouts, but that was with cheap tires on bad cars. This time, I was literally thinking, "is this the trip where I die because I didn't buy new tires???" Ugh! Anyway, I thought it was me, until I realized that so many have experienced this as a crappy model tire in an otherwise highly rated brand. Michelin has a long way to go to earn back my confidence after subjecting me to the "Cadillac Cimarron" of their tires.

Posted on michelinman.com

BamaJay, we regret to read that you are so disappointed in the Primacy All Season. I don't see that you have been in contact with us before now. Our team is here to help. We will be in touch to work with you and your retailer on initiating a warranty claim.

September 1, 2023

Posted On August 26, 2023 by Anonymous
Collected by Bazaarvoice
1/5

Horrible tire. Very Upsetting- should lasted longer

Very very dissatisfied that I have to put new tires on a 21 Ford bronco sport that only has 32,000 miles on it. I’m not mad at Ford at all as I am an employee lower models of bronco sports have continental tires on them that most forearms have said I’ve lasted way longer. I’m not the person that had the problem with the Outer Banks tire choice from the factory the Michelin primacy all season. Where markers are already showing and poor handling in the rain now moneys tight and I have to put tires on my car now not very happy.

Posted on michelinman.com
  • Photo
  • Photo
  • Photo
1 3

Ngibson260, sorry to read you are in need of replacing tires. A member of our team will be in touch to discuss replacement tire options.

August 29, 2023

1...141516...19